27 minutes ago, Walka003 said:

2 hours ago, valiant_593 said:

What other good signings did we make? Iacovetti is very poor. Chislett and Deborah great signings. Devine and Arblaster as well but both will probably go back. The rest have been very poor 

5 good signings out of 16, what a window!!

Where do you get 16 signings from? 

Where do you get 16 signings from? 

Ripley, Leutwiler, Yak, Lowe, Deborah, Sang, Grant, Clark, Balmer, Devine, Arblaster, Loft, Uche, Thomas, Chislett and Wilson (after releasing him).

I'd say Ripley, Jesse, Sang, Devine, Arblaster and Chizzy have been good. So 6 out of 16, or 37.5% success rate.

4 minutes ago, Walka003 said:

Ripley, Leutwiler, Yak, Lowe, Deborah, Sang, Grant, Clark, Balmer, Devine, Arblaster, Loft, Uche, Thomas, Chislett and Wilson (after releasing him).

I'd say Ripley, Jesse, Sang, Devine, Arblaster and Chizzy have been good. So 6 out of 16, or 37.5% success rate.

As good as Arblaster and Devine have been aswell we'll be lucky to see him in a vale shirt again so we've only had him half a season and Devine could be recalled and sent out to a higher standard team both of them had no right be as good as they have proven to be in my opinion they were chancer signings! Look at all the young lads on loan we've had in the past 2 seasons and how many can we say did the business?

18 minutes ago, Walka003 said:

Ripley, Leutwiler, Yak, Lowe, Deborah, Sang, Grant, Clark, Balmer, Devine, Arblaster, Loft, Uche, Thomas, Chislett and Wilson (after releasing him).

I'd say Ripley, Jesse, Sang, Devine, Arblaster and Chizzy have been good. So 6 out of 16, or 37.5% success rate.

I’d say we were talking about summer transfer signings and I wouldn’t count Wilson as a new signing so out of 14 it’s now closer to 50%. Didn’t Rudge say if you got half your signings right you’d done well? 

I’d say we were talking about summer transfer signings and I wouldn’t count Wilson as a new signing so out of 14 it’s now closer to 50%. Didn’t Rudge say if you got half your signings right you’d done well? 

How have you taken one player out and gotten to 14? I'd very much count Wilson considering our DoF and manager binned him then had to have him back when they couldn't replace him.

In this video (8 mins in) Clarke tells DF that we need to be aiming for 75% success. We've never even got close since we got to L1.

31 minutes ago, Walka003 said:

Thank god you said Cheltenham, I've been trying to figure out who 'nam are for half an hour

Chelt 'Nammm m8

8 minutes ago, Walka003 said:

How have you taken one player out and gotten to 14? I'd very much count Wilson considering our DoF and manager binned him then had to have him back when they couldn't replace him.

In this video (8 mins in) Clarke tells DF that we need to be aiming for 75% success. We've never even got close since we got to L1.
 

If he’s on about summer (in window signings) then I’m guessing he is excluding Uche but leaving in Jesse as he’s done well. 

So by that count it’s 5 in 14. Either way the window was a right mess again 

32 minutes ago, Walka003 said:

Ripley, Leutwiler, Yak, Lowe, Deborah, Sang, Grant, Clark, Balmer, Devine, Arblaster, Loft, Uche, Thomas, Chislett and Wilson (after releasing him).

I'd say Ripley, Jesse, Sang, Devine, Arblaster and Chizzy have been good. So 6 out of 16, or 37.5% success rate.

But the suggests that all the others are 'bad' - some of them I'd class as OK but not bad. 

However, we still need to clear out those that clearly are not up to the job and replace with better. 

 

If he’s on about summer (in window signings) then I’m guessing he is excluding Uche but leaving in Jesse as he’s done well. 
So by that count it’s 5 in 14. Either way the window was a right mess again 

Either take them both out or leave them both in if you're doing that. Don't just do whichever one suits your argument the best.

But the suggests that all the others are 'bad' - some of them I'd class as OK but not bad. 
However, we still need to clear out those that clearly are not up to the job and replace with better. 
 

I'd say the rest fall into three categories, crap, injury prone, or crap and injury prone.

Some have done OK in spells and been shocking in others (Yaks probably the prime example of this). That doesn't say to me good signing.

2 hours ago, Walka003 said:

So 6 out of 16, or 37.5% success rate.

In terms of the big picture, don't forget that under Flitcroft we've also signed Jones, Martin, Stone, Danny Amos, Hussey, Robinson, George Lloyd, Cooper, Holy, Agyawka, Holden, Thierry Small, Jack Stevens, Odubeko, McCarron, Donnelly, and Matty Taylor.

30 minutes ago, Doha said:

In terms of the big picture, don't forget that under Flitcroft we've also signed Jones, Martin, Stone, Danny Amos, Hussey, Robinson, George Lloyd, Cooper, Holy, Agyawka, Holden, Thierry Small, Jack Stevens, Odubeko, McCarron, Donnelly, and Matty Taylor.

There is some <ovf censored> no doubt but for balance you should be listing every player signed by Flitctoft to give an accurate picture. The signings for L2 were very good with the likes of Walker,Pett,Wilson,Proctor,Jones,Cass, Garrity etc. 

4 hours ago, EricHamesis said:

Vietnam is a hell of a commute.

I'll be very Hanoi'd if he goes there. 

12 minutes ago, MBE said:

There is some <ovf censored> no doubt but for balance you should be listing every player signed by Flitctoft to give an accurate picture. The signings for L2 were very good with the likes of Walker,Pett,Wilson,Proctor,Jones,Cass, Garrity etc. 

All subjective, obviously. Some are only elevated a tier or two because we flipped them for a profit.

Edited December 28, 20232 yr by Doha

For a laugh, here is the list of signings made by Port Vale since David Flitcroft became DoF:

Summer 2021 - Garrity, Benning, Covolan, Johnson, Jones, Martin, Pett, Stone, Walker, Wilson, Proctor, Amos, Cass (loan), Politic (loan), Lloyd (loan)

January 2022 - Hussey, Hall, Charsley, Robinson, Edmonson (loan), Harratt (loan), Holy (loan), Cooper (loan)

Summer 2022 - Cass, Ojo, Massey, Agyakwa, Forrester, Holden, Harrison, Small (loan), Stevens (loan), Odubeko (loan), Butterworth (loan), Politic (loan), McCarron (loan)

January 2023 - Donnelly (loan), Taylor (loan)

Summer 2023 - Grant, Iacovitti, Leutweiler, Ripley, Sang, Clark, Lowe, Loft, Debrah, Ikpeazu, Balmer (loan), Arblaster (loan), Thomas (loan), Devine (loan)

EDIT: Doha has done a far better list.

Edited December 28, 20232 yr by JoeB2