philpvfc

Are we not signing anyone else this window? 5 out, 3 in and we are one place off a relegation spot. Oh dear.

You seem to know a lot of certainties. Fancy letting us know what Fridays lotto numbers are?

If we don’t sign a decent striker, even on loan this window then once again, it has been a failure transfer window. Especially with Uche going off injured on Saturday.

In your opinion

So….you want him at the Vale because he got a team up with by far the highest budget last season, and got them up via the play offs with a last minute extra time goal against Barnsley. We won’t have any where near as much budget as Wednesday so how do you think he will get on with the Vale?

Didn’t say he was a bad manager, just pointing out his history. I would say he is unproven to a certain degree, not been given a fair chance whether that’s been for good reason or not. I thought it was strange sacking him after getting Wednesday up, but on the flip side, they had by far the biggest budget last season, and went up via the play offs to a last minute injury time goal against 10 man Barnsley, so he didn’t work wonders for them.

Why do you think that? Managed 4 clubs, not lasted longer than 18 months at any of them and sacked by 3 of them. 3 wins out of 23 this season at Huddersfield.

Think he’d be naff there too.

Don’t tell Brian

Putting up as much fight as we did.

Nearly all league one clubs now try to play possession football, in fact can’t think of one that is very direct.

Why didn’t he play for 8 months? As far as I’m aware, it’s not because of injury. If that is the case then there is no excuse for not being fit, he’s a professional footballer and is paid to keep fit and ready to play if needed. I understand the case for match sharpness but that should not take more than a month to get back to full speed. He’s been with us plenty of time to be fully up to speed unless there is an underlying injury that we are not aware of, but saying that it should have been picked up by our medical team when joining the club.

Have you seen our squad over the last couple of seasons?

I just mentioned signings, but that makes it all the worse. You on about the same Taylor? The Taylor who can’t make the FGR team who are sitting near the bottom of division 2

Loft, Donnelly, Taylor.

Who? Balmer, Innis? Innis was quality, Balmer wasn’t the best but was no way as bad as soon other signings we have made of late.

For the vast majority of the time at Vale he has not been a good footballer. Losing Uche at this time is a loss for us but only for the simple fact we do not have anyone else any better. He was showing signs of improvement and could be a handful for defenders at times but let’s not kid ourselves he was a quality forward, some very over complimentary comments going on about him now we are about to lose him.

If we lose Uche and Wilson gets injured (both likely), plus the fact we have let Thomas go back, does that make us entirely reliable on Loft upfront? How many points are we off relegation?

Can’t see him getting game time at Plymouth unless they have injury problems.

Remember seeing him play for Liverpool in the CL and he looked a great prospect, not out of place in a strong Liverpool team. Obviously lost his way since then but if can get that form back and stay fit he will be a massive asset to us.

Oh yes I do. As I said, 3600 so probably closer to their average crowd than the 17,700 I was quoting against. You can carry it on but you are wrong.

Fans have every right to criticise should they wish but can’t blame Crosby for bad signings then compliment someone else for the good signings.

I know some people slag off Crosby but he has brought some good footballers in at the Vale but not including Loft. You can’t blame Crosby for some of the crap he has to work with but not compliment him when happy with the signings, it’s either or.