Skip to content
Advert

Rob Fielding

Rob Fielding is the editor of onevalefan and has been a Port Vale FC fan since 1980. He has written about Port Vale for 30 years. Rob has worked in many roles including in sports journalism and marketing. He has written a Port Vale book “No Ordinary Season” and curated the “Vale Vaults” Port Vale memorabilia exhibition. Rob has appeared on numerous radio broadcasts and podcasts (including BBC Radio Stoke) and written for multiple publications (including submissions for the Guardian, 442 and Word Soccer) about his club. His favourite player is striker Andy Jones and his favourite match is the FA Cup win over Spurs in 1988.

4 Comments

George Byers has been targeted for criticism this season. Ineffective performances characterized by sideways and backwards passing that put the hand brake on attacks, and failure to add creativity, frustrated supporters. Then came Moore’s decision not to select him for the match day squad. The outcome was Byers back at Luton, performing to higher expectations. Does Moore get credit for this ? Seems logical, as does him persisting with a flexible a 442 formation. Praise too for Ben Waine’s resurgence. It seems Moore has found a successful niche for him in a left sided forward role. This is reminiscent of John Rudge’s 1988-89 decision to move central striker David Riley to the same role, supporting Futcher and Beckford in that season’s promotion team. Did Moore get tip off advice from canny Rudge ? Either way, Waine is scoring goals and giving the attack an unexpected new dimension.

Ian Mountford

As I said, everyone played well on Saturday but Byers did standout. The odd thing was, Byers did this interview saying how he and the players needed to up their game, and we get a display like that. Whether it’s the change in formation, or playing a long side Ojo I don’t know, but it’s no coincidence that once Moores ridiculous formations and tactics are out of the window, it’s like an enormous weight has been lifted off the players. I just HOPE the owners take all this onboard and they realise Moores vision of systems and tactics is and has ruined so many players at the club. None of our youngsters are progressing and that performance and the players performances, was unrecognisable from what we have been watching. Although you don’t agree with me thoughts Rob, this is the second time in 12 months Moore has been forced to ditch his systems and tactics in hope of saving the season. Moore has got to go for the sake of the club and players.

Erm, Ian Mountford I don’t get your comment. You say you have a similar view on Byers (and have said similar things on other posts) and then say I disagree with you. If we’re both having the same thoughts then we agree! Not on everything but on a lot of things. For instance, I’ve talked for a long time about him needing to learn from last season’s tactics. So, I’m not entirely sure why you say we don’t agree. I would say we do – not 100% – but on a lot of things.

I’m sorry to put adampener on things but one swallow doesn’t make a Summer I’m glad that the Vale seem to be playing better but two wins in the cups against poor opponents and a draw against a team that is also out of form and a manager under pressure I have yet again to ask the question WHY has it taken DM so long to see HIS tactics didn’t work nobody will be more pleased if we get out of this hole but I cannot see us stringing 4 or 5 wins together especially over a crowded Xmas period if we loose the two away games and get little from the home games we can kiss this league goodbye.