onevalefan.co.ukonevalefan.co.uk
  • Home
  • Forum
  • News
    • Headlines
    • Published elsewhere
    • Former Valiants
    • Rumours
    • Interviews
    • The administration months
    • Reference & special features
  • Blogs
    • Rob Fielding
    • Malcolm Hirst
    • Ray Williams
    • Barry Edge
    • Barry Edge poetry
    • Kitman confessions
    • All blogs
  • Nostalgia
    • Club History
    • Club Legends
    • Cult heroes
    • Legends of 1954
    • The Sprosons
    • Classic matches
    • Vintage Vale Park
    • Centrefold interviews
    • Nearly Men
    • Programme covers
    • Programme reviews
    • Video vault
    • All-time appearances
    • All-time scorers
    • Kit database
    • Port Vale Managers
    • Player Database
    • Vale Vaults
    • Scrapbooks & clippings
    • Tributes & obituaries
    • 1000s of pictures
  • About
    • About the site
    • Contact us
    • What they say about OVF
  • Site Map
portvale
12 March 2018

Opinion: fighting Port Vale fans should be banned for life

Rob Fielding Malcolm Hirst blog

Columnist Malcolm Hirst says there are simply no excuses for the fans hell-bent on violence at the Grimsby Town match…

Malcolm Hirst writes…

I hope those involved can be identified from CCTV in the ground and the police videos, and that they will be banned by Port Vale for life. Sadly, this kind of behaviour is an ongoing problem for Vale and needs to be tackled…

Following Port Vale has been a rollercoaster ride for the last few years. Little did I think that I could go from the heights of the Fans’ Forum on Thursday evening to the depths of shame of Saturday afternoon.

It was great to welcome representatives of ‘Kick It Out’ and ‘Fans for Diversity’ to Vale Park for the Fans’ Forum. Despite initially feeling disappointed with the low numbers who attend a meeting that also included the presence of Neil Aspin and John Rudge, I came away feeling positive.

The engagement of the those present with the difficult topics of racism and diversity made me proud to be a Vale fan and gave me hope for the future. It may take a while, and may need many small steps, but I believe we can build a welcoming and diverse fan base. I heard plenty of positive feedback from the evening. My thanks go to Anwar Uddin and Paul Mortimer for their input in the evening, and to Ally Simcock for organising the evening. It will be wonderful to build on this positive start.

What a contrast it was only twenty hours later when individuals from Stoke-on-Trent and Grimsby ran towards each other intent on causing trouble and bringing shame, and probably fines, on both clubs. I use the word ‘individuals’ purposefully. Let’s be clear the individuals involved in this trouble on Saturday are not football fans. I’ve seen them described in several ways on social media. The words and phrases used have been; absolute scum, hooligans, 70’s and 80’s mentality, thugs and yobs.

I hope those involved can be identified from CCTV in the ground and the police videos, and that they will be banned by Port Vale for life. Sadly, this kind of behaviour is an ongoing problem for Vale and needs to be tackled. I know people who will not go to certain away games that are likely to be targeted by the above individuals. I am uncomfortable with the idea of an ‘identity scheme’ for away matches. However, after Saturday, I am beginning to think I would be willing to sacrifice that principle in order to build a better Port Vale.

@nlvmalc

This column represents the columnist’s personal views and not necessarily those of the Port Vale Supporters Club.

Print

Opinion: worrying times for Vale fans are owner’s not manager’s fault Opinion: is it all pretence?

Related Posts

stand_down_Beat

Malcolm Hirst blog

Opinion: is it all pretence?

Columnist Malcolm Hirst says ahead of the supporters’ meeting it’s time to “stand down Norman, stand down please…”

railway-seats-2018

Malcolm Hirst blog

Opinion: worrying times for Vale fans are owner’s not manager’s fault

Columnist Malcolm Hirst says that the club’s Football League future could be in serious doubt and that one person will be to blame if it does go down…

2017-bycars

Malcolm Hirst blog

Opinion: now the Hugill deal is done where should the money go?

Columnist Malcolm Hirst says that the Hugill money should be split between investment in the squad and paying off directors’ loans.

shop

Malcolm Hirst blog

Malcolm Hirst: what we require at Vale Park is a period of stability and unity

Columnist Malcolm Hirst says that following the appointment of Neil Aspin and John Rudge Port Vale now need to build for the future.

lorne-st

Malcolm Hirst blog

Malcolm Hirst: despite the owner’s tweets, this mess isn’t the fans’ fault

Columnist Malcolm Hirst says that despite tweets from owner Norman Smurthwaite, most Vale fans know where the club’s current problems stem from.

lorne-corner

Malcolm Hirst blog

Malcolm Hirst: Rudderless Port Vale are suffering from a lack of leadership

Columnist Malcolm Hirst says that the rudderless club are in danger of having just non-league football to look forward to.

Search

Local sponsors

BODEN ROOFING LTD
all roofing work undertaken

bodenroofingltd.co.uk
10% discount for Vale season ticket holders
VALIANT WINDOW CLEANING SERVICE
Contract/domestic work undertaken. Can clean upto 60ft
Call/text Adam 0774 2916 242 adamfozzer@hotmail.co.uk

Advert

Advert

Help with our costs

Advert

Your login

register or login

Latest posts

  • If you are betting on Vale get a free bet first at www.thebookiesoffers.co.uk

Advert

Next up…

Results

This day in history…

  • 1957 David Raine makes his Port Vale debut in a 2-1 win over Rotherham United.
  • 1974 John Woodward scores twice as Port Vale beat Charlton Athletic 3-1.
  • 1985 Ally Brown, Robbie Earle and Oshor Williams score as Port Vale beat Halifax Town 3-1.
  • 1999 Stewart Talbot has his leg broken after a dreadful challenge by Watford player Paul Robinson.
  • 2012 Club creditors approve the deal for Keith Ryder to buy the football club. Ryder never completes the deal.

Advert

Advert

Advert

Advert

Featured on

As featured on NewsNow: Port Vale news
Port Vale News 24/7 

Get email alerts of new posts

Thanks for subscribing!

  • Media bookings
  • Contact us
  • About this website
  • About cookies

Fixtures and tickets

About this site

We aim to be a responsible website. There are occasional gambling promotions on here and we encourage all users to gamble responsibly and know your limits. Find more help here.

This website opposes racism, homophobia and bigotry of all kinds. We accept no responsibility for views posted in the forum. We will respond as quickly as possible if you report a post to help@onevalefan.co.uk.

We support two chosen charities - the Donna Louise Trust and the Douglas MacMillan Hospice and donate to both.

All images and text (c) onevalefan.co.uk unless stated. Please ask us before using our content. We use cookies to enhance your enjoyment of this site | Cookie and privacy policy