onevalefan.co.ukonevalefan.co.uk
  • Home
  • Forum
  • News
    • Headlines
    • Published elsewhere
    • Former Valiants
    • Rumours
    • Interviews
    • The administration months
    • Reference & special features
  • Blogs
    • Rob Fielding
    • Malcolm Hirst
    • Ray Williams
    • Barry Edge
    • Barry Edge poetry
    • Kitman confessions
    • All blogs
  • Nostalgia
    • Club History
    • Club Legends
    • Cult heroes
    • Legends of 1954
    • The Sprosons
    • Classic matches
    • Vintage Vale Park
    • Centrefold interviews
    • Nearly Men
    • Programme covers
    • Programme reviews
    • Video vault
    • All-time appearances
    • All-time scorers
    • Kit database
    • Port Vale Managers
    • Player Database
    • Vale Vaults
    • Scrapbooks & clippings
    • Tributes & obituaries
    • 1000s of pictures
  • About
    • About the site
    • Contact us
    • What they say about OVF
  • Site Map
ovf
4 February 2014

Vale right to use OVF as sounding board

Rob Rob Fielding blog

Rob Fielding feels obliged to defend the club and this website over a recent article on the club’s proposed new kit.

You’d probably have guessed this already but I get quite a few comments from fellow fans sent to me. So, I was rather surprised when amongst the expected items – Micky Adams’ contract, Tom Pope’s form and Norman Smurthwaite’s intentions I was told there had been the odd comment criticising OVF’s recent feature – “should this be Vale’s next away kit?”

It seems that some folks think that Port Vale FC should not be giving this sort of information to a mere fans site like OVF. I find that attitude surprising and frankly wrong.

I tend to think that criticising the club for their kit poll is just moaning for moaning’s sake…

I can understand that some supporters do not agree with Norman Smurthwaite’s style of ownership, but I tend to think that criticising the club for their kit poll is just moaning for moaning’s sake.

Aferall, I seem to remember we had a “few” kit problems last season. Not only was there the lengthy third kit delays but the home and away kits did not arrive for quite some time.

So, why was this article a good idea?

Firstly, Vale are clearly looking at kit designs earlier this season, Isn’t that a good thing and will hopefully ensure the kits arrive in good time in the summer?

Secondly, Vale aren’t addressing their entire fanbase but they are addressing a significant part of it (last time I checked over 20,000 different individuals came to OVF last month) to see if they like the design. It’s surely a good idea to check if people like the design if they want to sell the kit.

And what’s wrong with engaging free market research? Surely, we want the club to be understanding of our views as fans?

Point three – this is market research (and free as we don’t charge anything for publishing such a story). Other methods such as polling fans at matches or via the programme will cost both money and resources. Putting a simple poll on a fans’ site is both immediate, free and simple. And what’s wrong with engaging free market research? Surely, we want the club to be understanding of our views as fans? After all, one of the chief criticisms of V2001 was that they disregarded the views of the fans.

You’re bound to say all of that, you may argue, as you run OVF. Well, yes but I was asked by the club to run this, I didn’t approach them. And I did it because as a fans’ site, we want Port Vale to progress and I felt that polling the fans about a new design would help the club – as a popular design would potentially sell more shirts and earn more money for Vale.

After all, this article doesn’t mean OVF supplanting the official club website as the first place for club statements, news and the like – it’s a sensible use of a fans site for a specific purpose – in order to poll the fanbase. It’s not like OVF is suddenly running club statements and announcements ahead of the official website or indeed the local press. We don’t and we won’t.

And I would argue that if you want to offer criticism of the current Vale regime, their editorial policy should be a very low priority. What about the far more important issue of the manager’s contract, for instance?

The very same people would be moaning and asking why the club hadn’t asked the fans if they liked the design first…

Forgive me for a bad pun but things are not “black and white” in Port Vale world. Norman Smurthwaite doesn’t get everything right but neither does he get everything wrong. I think sometimes it’s too much for some people to acknowledge that sometimes the owner does actually get things right. After all, I bet if the club simply released a kit design without polling the fans and it proved unpopular, the very same people would be moaning and asking why the club hadn’t asked the fans if they liked the design first…

I personally feel it’s much fairer to criticise the club when criticism is due and praise it when praise is due. So, while I criticise the club over delays to Micky Adams’ contract, I will praise them over asking the fans about a kit design. That’s only fair isn’t it?

Print

Adams contract should be no.1 priority I’m hoping the hard work pays off

Related Posts

entrance-2018

Rob Fielding blog

Opinion: despite the Q&A, Port Vale’s finances don’t add up

Rob Fielding says that one conclusion that many fans will draw from the Q&A meeting with Norman Smurthwaite on Thursday is that the club’s finances just don’t seem to add up.

2017-turnstiles

Rob Fielding blog

Vale need clear long-term plans and if not, a change of ownership

Rob Fielding says the club need to either produce a long-term, coherent vision or sell to new owners who can deliver that vision.

2017-vale-park-clouds2

Rob Fielding blog

Opinion: Hugill fee shows that having a clear transfer policy works

Rob Fielding says that the Jordan Hugill fee justifies the creation of a development squad and that fans and owner should now show some patience with the club’s focus on developing non-league talent.

2017-turnstiles

Rob Fielding blog

Opinion: Struggling Vale cannot afford another deadline disaster

Rob Fielding says that a second successive appalling transfer window could send the club spiralling into danger.

aspin-alt3

Rob Fielding blog

Aspin is taking Vale in right direction but he is no miracle worker

OVF editor Rob Fielding says some fans have unrealistic expectations of the Port Vale manager.

fred-pitch

Rob Fielding blog

A few words of praise for Port Vale’s unsung stars

Rob Fielding would like to praise some unsung members of the Port Vale FC’s backroom team.

Search

Local sponsors

BODEN ROOFING LTD
all roofing work undertaken

bodenroofingltd.co.uk
10% discount for Vale season ticket holders
VALIANT WINDOW CLEANING SERVICE
Contract/domestic work undertaken. Can clean upto 60ft
Call/text Adam 0774 2916 242 adamfozzer@hotmail.co.uk

Advert

Advert

Help with our costs

Advert

Your login

register or login

Latest posts

  • If you are betting on Vale get a free bet first at www.thebookiesoffers.co.uk

Advert

Next up…

Results

This day in history…

  • 1955 Port Vale's highest official league attendance of 40,066 is recorded for a game against Stoke City.
  • 1955 Port Vale record their highest league attendance of 40,066 for a game against Stoke City.
  • 1980 Tony Sealy scores the winner as Port Vale beat Stockport County 1-0.
  • 1988 Gary Ford and Ray Walker score as Port Vale beat Wigan Athletic 2-1.
  • 2015 Tom Pope scores his final Port Vale goal as Vale beat Yeovil 2-1.

Advert

Advert

Advert

Advert

Featured on

As featured on NewsNow: Port Vale news
Port Vale News 24/7 

Get email alerts of new posts

Thanks for subscribing!

  • Media bookings
  • Contact us
  • About this website
  • About cookies

Fixtures and tickets

About this site

We aim to be a responsible website. There are occasional gambling promotions on here and we encourage all users to gamble responsibly and know your limits. Find more help here.

This website opposes racism, homophobia and bigotry of all kinds. We accept no responsibility for views posted in the forum. We will respond as quickly as possible if you report a post to help@onevalefan.co.uk.

We support two chosen charities - the Donna Louise Trust and the Douglas MacMillan Hospice and donate to both.

All images and text (c) onevalefan.co.uk unless stated. Please ask us before using our content. We use cookies to enhance your enjoyment of this site | Cookie and privacy policy